Papa Johns Pizza in Wisconsin

"Placed a large order over the phone for pickup in two hours. Christian took my order and even talked me through the best deal for the amount of people we were trying to serve. The manager called me back in thirty minutes saying he could not fill the order for 3.5 hours because staff called in sick. We finally settled on having him just make it when he could and keep it warm in his ovens until our pickup time. Everything was hot and ready when we arrived to pick up."

"The only papa John's I love to go to for family night pizza night! Customer service is always good and welcoming. I know everyone has their own opinions. But I am always in and out without a complaint."

"I always order carry out for my pizzas and they never really fail me .. My fav pizza spot.... Always order with extra cheese for it to look how mine look lol"

"Initially undercooked our pizzas, but delivered new fully cooked ones. 4/5 stars for quick attentive service. But we shouldn’t have to call to have more pizzas delivered. It should be cooked thoroughly the 1st time."

"Pizza was great as always but the crust was wrong. It's on me for not checking it prior to leaving with my carryout but I guess I'm stuck thinking I shouldn't have to...that said, it was still delicious, timely, and staff was friendly"

"I'm not sure why this place has such bad reviews. I've ordered from here multiple times and never had a bad experience. For chain pizza, I think it's great. Wouldn't hesitate to order again."

"I was nervous after reading some reviews but gave it a shot. 25 minute wait on a Saturday didn't seem bad and the food was ready on time for pick up and order was correct. I hadn't had Papa Johns in a few year and it was better than I remember. No complaints!"

"When I arrived my large pizza and breadstick order was ready. The woman at the register went to grab that, while a gentleman asked if I needed anything else. I asked for plates as I was feeding 10 kids and was immediately given plates and an easy access bunch of napkins. I’m kind of obsessed with how great they are. The napkins. Together they bagged my order and accessories. All the while I am watching as a young man who was clearly already punched out for the day, answered the phone with a smile as another coworker happily but jeeringly rolled her eyes. As if to say, overachiever. Truly a great experience. I have ordered here in the past plenty, but this last week I got a full experience of what is happening there right now. Seemed like a great team. And very well staffed. I’d say I saw at least 8 employees, in the store, working hard on a Friday night at 4:45pm. Not a lot of great service out there these days, and so it was super refreshing."